I’m a bit late to this, but I’m sharing my thoughts nonetheless, for the next person who’s curious at least. Personally, I can’t recommend the Ear (Stick) enough! I actually believe they fit better than products with silicone tips (I have the Ear (1) too), though I think that’s something that varies from person to person.
I dont use the noise cancelling on the Ear (Stick), since I feel like that’s not what they’re made for (and also not what they’re great at). But that actually makes them great for having clear direct sound channeling, while still allowing in some true ambient noise from your surroundings. I really want to try the Ear (Open) at some point, but for my purposes, the Ear (Stick) are great